SEND Scrutiny: Relational, Appreciative Governance in Practice
Blog overview
In the first blog in this series, Su reflected on what more than 25 years of scrutiny has taught us; and why scrutiny works best when it is relational, appreciative and grounded in trust rather than tension.
This second blog brings that thinking to life through a practical example: SEND scrutiny. SEND sits in one of the most complex and pressured areas of local government, spanning education, health, care, finance and lived experience. In this context, how scrutiny is exercised matters; not just for accountability, but for the relationships that underpin system-wide improvement.
Drawing on national work and experience supporting councils, Su explores SEND scrutiny as an example of relational, appreciative governance in practice. The blog reflects on why traditional, deficit-focused scrutiny can unintentionally reinforce defensiveness, and how a more appreciative approach can strengthen challenge, support learning and improve outcomes for children and families.
Part 2
Why SEND scrutiny matters so much
SEND sits at the intersection of education, health, care, finance and lived experience. It is emotionally charged, systemically complex and under intense national pressure. Families are navigating systems that often feel fragmented and exhausting, while councils are working within significant financial and operational constraints.
In this context, traditional, deficit-based scrutiny, focused primarily on what is failing can unintentionally reinforce defensiveness, mistrust and siloed working.
That does not mean challenge is inappropriate. It means the way challenge is exercised matters more than ever.
Putting relational scrutiny into practice
The LGA's recently published SEND scrutiny resource was developed to help scrutiny councillors and officers navigate this complexity more effectively.
I was pleased to contribute to the guide, which reflects a relational model of scrutiny focused on learning, trust and system-wide improvement, and builds on my work around appreciative governance.
Rather than positioning scrutiny as an inspection function, the resource encourages scrutiny committees to:
- focus on understanding what is working as well as what is not;
- create shared ownership of challenges across the system;
- use scrutiny’s influence to support improvement for children and families, rather than apportioning blame.
In the guide, this is described as an appreciative approach; one that sees strengths-based questioning and relational working not as “soft”, but as a powerful route to stronger accountability and better outcomes.
What this looks like in practice
Through my work with councils, and reflected in the SEND scrutiny resource; several relational practices consistently make the biggest difference:
1. Creating shared spaces early in the policy cycle
Scrutiny councillors, executives and officers exploring SEND pressures together at the outset; not once decisions have already been formed. In practice, this might mean joint conversations about demand pressures or system capacity before proposals are drafted, rather than debating them once positions are fixed.
2. Moving from deficit challenge to appreciative inquiry
Reframing questions from “what’s gone wrong?” to: What’s working despite the pressure? Where are the strengths in the system? What would help this land better for children and families?
3. Officers enabling, not filtering, dialogue
Creating space for direct, transparent conversations, with officers supporting clarity and shared understanding across the system.
4. Regularly resetting roles and expectations
SEND systems change rapidly. Returning to role clarity builds confidence, trust and permission for honest conversations. These approaches do not dilute scrutiny’s role; they strengthen it by creating the conditions for more honest dialogue and more meaningful influence.
Scrutiny after 25 years: a relationship reset
Scrutiny exists to strengthen democratic accountability and improve decision-making and outcomes.
It works best when it is understood as a constructive, non-political function; and when the executive sees challenge as a contributor to better decisions, not a barrier to them.
SEND scrutiny, at its best, becomes a space for learning, insight and collective problem-solving. That only happens when scrutiny and the executive recognise their roles as different, but complementary; aligned in purpose even when perspectives differ.
To do this well, scrutiny needs:
- access
- respect
- openness
- meaningful involvement in shaping decisions
And the executive needs:
- confidence in scrutiny
- assurance that challenge comes with care
- recognition that constructive dialogue strengthens, rather than delays, improvement
The Scrutiny Effect
This is what I describe as the Scrutiny Effect; the organisational impact that emerges when scrutiny is confident, relational and improvement-focused.
When scrutiny is well-led and relational, it creates a ripple effect beyond formal meetings or committee rooms. Decision-making becomes more transparent. Services become more accountable. A stronger culture of learning and reflection begins to take hold.
Officers prepare more thoughtfully. Executive Councillors reflect more carefully. Residents can see that their concerns are being taken seriously.
In this way, scrutiny becomes more than a process; it becomes a mindset; one that supports better outcomes, builds trust and strengthens local democracy.
Where next?
If more than 25 years of scrutiny has taught us anything, it is this:
Structures matter; but relationships matter more.
The opportunity now is to shift the focus from “what is wrong” to “what enables scrutiny to work well”, and to invest intentionally in the relationships that make that possible.
That means:
- investing in trust
- strengthening communication
- developing scrutiny and executives together
- building governance cultures where learning is valued over defensiveness
For councils looking to reflect on their own approach, the Local Government Association’s SEND scrutiny resource provides a helpful place to start. It brings together practical prompts and examples to support councillors and officers to undertake their own review, and to consider how scrutiny is working in their local context.
Because after more than 25 years, we know what scrutiny is. The challenge now is not redefining scrutiny, but creating the conditions in which it can work well.
That is where the future of scrutiny lies.
And that is where I will continue to focus my work; supporting councils to move from transactional scrutiny to relational scrutiny, from deficit to appreciative governance, and from “checking up” to working together.
Especially for our most vulnerable children and families.
About the Author
Su is the Chief Executive of Shaping Governance and a Governance Associate for the LGA. She works nationally with councils to strengthen governance, overview and scrutiny, SEND scrutiny, corporate parenting and partnership working.
Su specialises in relational and appreciative approaches that help boards and committees work together with greater trust and impact. She contributed to the newly published SEND scrutiny resource and, over the last four years, has played a key role in co-developing and delivering the LGA’s sector offer for Children’s Overview and Scrutiny and Corporate Parenting.
