Scrutiny at 25: The Case for Relational Governance
Blog overview
Overview and scrutiny has been part of local government for more than 25 years. During that time, structures have evolved, guidance has been refined and expectations have grown. Yet many councils continue to ask the same question: how can scrutiny be more effective?
This two-part blog series reflects on what more than two decades of practice has taught us. It argues that scrutiny works best when it is relational; grounded in trust, shared understanding and constructive challenge, and explores how an appreciative approach can strengthen accountability rather than dilute it.
In Part 2, SEND scrutiny is used as a practical example of what this looks like in practice.
Part 1
It is now more than 25 years since overview and scrutiny committees became part of local government. Over a quarter of a century of committed councillors, call-ins, task groups and countless hours dedicated to improving outcomes for communities.
And yet, in the work I do with councils, the same conversations continue to surface. Not about structures, guidance or powers; but about relationships.
Questions about scrutiny’s role. Debates about its value. A persistent sense that “scrutiny could be more effective.”
After more than 25 years, perhaps the question is no longer what scrutiny is meant to do, but what conditions allow it to work at its best. What I see, time and again, is that those conditions are relational.
Despite guidance, best practice and decades of collective experience, the greatest opportunities for improvement lie not in structures or processes, but in how people work together.
I shared this message recently at a Lead Member Network: that scrutiny’s success depends on relationships. The discussion that followed showed just how strongly this resonates across the sector right now.
Scrutiny’s influence is relational
Scrutiny’s potential is unlocked through stronger relationships across the system; between scrutiny and the executive, officers and partners.
These relationships do not weaken accountability; they strengthen it by creating openness, trust and shared understanding.
At its heart, scrutiny’s power lies in influence rather than formal authority. That influence is only ever as strong as the relationships that underpin it.
Relationships are not a “soft” addition to scrutiny; they are its foundation.
By relational governance, I mean scrutiny that is intentionally built on trust, shared understanding and constructive challenge, rather than transactional interactions or periodic confrontation.
In my view, the relationships around scrutiny simply need more deliberate attention if scrutiny is to thrive. We do not have a scrutiny problem; we have a relationship opportunity.
What councils continue to experience
Across councils, I hear the same frustrations repeated:
- Scrutiny committees feeling disconnected from early policy development
- Executives experiencing scrutiny as something that happens “after the fact”
- A lingering perception that scrutiny equals challenge, and challenge equals conflict
This dynamic is not accidental; it is a legacy.
Overview and scrutiny was introduced to create democratic balance, but the relationships needed to make it work were largely left to develop organically. Some councils invested in them. Others assumed they would settle naturally. Many came to accept tension as the norm.
That tension still shows up today; in defensive tones, cautious dialogue, blurred roles and a shared fear of being judged rather than supported.
A deliberate shift in approach
Over many years, I’ve supported councils to strengthen scrutiny and reset relationships. This year, however, I made a deliberate shift, adopting a more intentional, appreciative approach to how scrutiny is supported and developed.
Rather than starting with what isn’t working, this approach begins with curiosity: understanding strengths, building trust early, and creating the conditions for more open, constructive dialogue.
The impact has been noticeable. Not because accountability has been softened, but because it has been strengthened through better relationships.
This shift has reinforced something I feel strongly about: the effectiveness of scrutiny is shaped less by frameworks and more by how people work together within the system.
In Part 2, I bring this thinking to life through SEND scrutiny; using one of the most complex areas councils face to show how appreciative, relational scrutiny works in practice, and reflecting on a newly published Local Government Association resource that captures this shift.
