Governance Reviews & Evaluation

Independent 360° reviews, delivered through our signature, appreciative approach to governance

Good governance isn’t just about assurance or compliance. It’s about confidence, clarity and impact.

At Shaping Governance, our governance reviews and evaluations help boards understand what’s working, what matters most, and where to focus next; strengthening governance in ways that are purposeful, people-centred and sustainable.

This page sets out the different ways you can work with us to review your governance.

From diagnostic insight (Map it), through strategic development (Shape it), to formal external review (ERG it);

all delivered through our Signature Approach to Governance Reviews.

Governance Mapping

(Skills & Confidence Map)

Our Map provides a focused snapshot of governance effectiveness, going beyond a traditional skills audit to help boards identify strengths and priorities, spot patterns and themes, and agree clear next steps.

Explore Governance Mapping

Facilitated Strategic Development

(The Shaping Governance Programme)

Governance evaluation combined with expert facilitated strategic development, supporting boards to embed reflection, learning and improvement over time; and become a better team.

Explore the Shaping Governance Programme

External Review of Governance

(Independent assurance & evaluation)

An independent 360° review providing objective assurance, clear findings and practical recommendations, delivered through our signature approach so the process is rigorous, proportionate and constructive.

Learn more about External Reviews of Governance

Our Signature Approach & What You Can Expect

All our governance reviews are delivered through a signature, appreciative and evidence-led approach, designed to build confidence, support learning and lead to purposeful action. We focus on strengths as well as risks, learning rather than fault-finding, and insight that supports open, constructive conversations and meaningful improvement.

Across all governance reviews, you can expect a clear, agreed scope; proportionate evidence-gathering; insight you can act on; clear reporting and recommendations; and optional follow-up support.

If you’re unsure which approach is right for you, a short scoping conversation will help clarify what you want from a review, the level of depth or independence required, and the most appropriate route for your board.

"Through a rigorous and robust process, with the engagement of governance and senior leaders, Su was able to provide, at school and MAC level, a clear evaluation of how we can enhance performance and improve further.  Su also recognised the distinctive difference of our MAC with a Catholic dimension"

Romero Catholic Academy
'What an amazing addition Su Turner has been to our reflect and review process for school governance She brings a wealth of experience and is a patient facilitator who brings out the very best in our governing body... We start each academic year with our Shaping Governance review.'

Nikki Lawton, Head at Pebble Brook School
"Su’s approach is participative and guides Elected Members through what good corporate parenting looks like so that they can benchmark their approach. Elected Members are key to good corporate parenting and they leave the training programme understanding their role as a Corporate Parent and practical ways in which they can carry out the role effectively."

Dr Lee-Anne Farach, Medway Council
"We highly recommend Shaping Governance to other MACs or MATs that are looking to review their governance. It’s a very supportive and productive process. Su is incredibly professional. The process has exceeded our expectations.”

Local Government Association
"Su has an outstanding reputation in governance, health, and education, playing a key strategic role in enabling effective partnerships and positive outcomes for charities and public sector bodies throughout the UK. She is dynamic in her approach, working at the cutting edge of thinking at a regional and national level. Organisations in the public, private and charitable sectors would benefit from her insights and ability to bring people together to improve outcomes for their customers/clients."

Laura Murphy, Mtc2 Ltd

Governance Reviews & Evaluation FAQ

What do you mean by a governance review or evaluation?

A governance review or evaluation provides structured insight into how well governance is working in practice; not just on paper. It helps boards understand strengths, priorities and opportunities for improvement, and supports more confident, effective decision-making.

Our reviews go beyond compliance to explore how governance is experienced, how it supports strategy, and where it can have greater impact.

What makes your approach to governance review different?

All our reviews are delivered through our Signature Approach to Governance Reviews.

This approach is:

  • appreciative and strengths-based, not deficit-led

  • evidence-informed but proportionate

  • focused on learning, confidence and impact rather than fault-finding

We create the conditions for open, constructive conversations that help boards move from insight to action with clarity and purpose.

What types of governance review do you offer?

We offer three main routes, depending on your needs:

  • Diagnostic governance mapping (Skills & Confidence Map) for focused insight and prioritisation

  • The Shaping Governance Programme, combining evaluation with development and improvement support

  • External Reviews of Governance (ERG), providing independent, formal assurance

Each option uses the same signature approach, but with a different depth, scope and outcome.

How do we know which option is right for us?

You don’t need to decide alone.

We start with a short scoping conversation to understand:

  • your context and priorities

  • what you want from a review

  • the level of depth and independence required

We’ll then recommend the most appropriate route, or a phased approach, based on what will be most useful for your board.

Are your governance reviews just for schools and trusts?

While much of our work is in education, our governance reviews also support councils, partnerships and public sector boards.

Our approach is adaptable, grounded in good governance principles, and shaped to the context you’re working in.

Will this feel like an inspection or audit?

No.

While our work is rigorous and evidence-led, our approach is deliberately non-judgemental and constructive. Boards consistently tell us the process feels reflective, enabling and confidence-building rather than intimidating.

How long does a governance review take?

Timescales vary depending on the type of review and scope agreed.

Diagnostic mapping can be completed relatively quickly, while programmes and external reviews take place over a longer, agreed period. We always work proportionately and to clear timescales.