Why it’s time to change the way we look at Skills Audits

Why it’s time to change the way we look at Skills Audits 

As the new academic year approaches, boards up and down the country are dusting off their autumn checklists. Right near the top of that list is completing the Annual Skills Audit.

For most governors and trustees, this means opening a spreadsheet, ticking a few boxes about professional backgrounds, and sending it off to the Clerk. But does a spreadsheet full of experience really tell you how effectively your board operates in practice?

We know it’s important to understand the skills that governors bring, and that a governor that has accounting or HR experience is helpful to boards, but knowing whether they actually feel comfortable challenging senior leaders on budget assumptions, inclusion, or safeguarding is what actually impacts school governance.

Moving From Skills to Confidence

At Shaping Governance, we felt traditional skills audits only scratched the surface. While annual audits are recommended to assess board capability, our Skills & Confidence Map goes a step further. It explores not just what skills exist, but how confidently and effectively they are used in practice

As founder Su Turner explains:

“I believe that Skills Audits should build confidence, not just compliance. Governors bring many assets beyond a CV. When we focus on strengths rather than ticking boxes, we create the conditions for real collective impact.”

Skills on paper don't automatically translate to impact in the boardroom. That is why we have developed a new approach (the Skills and Confidence Map) that focuses on more than just skills and experience; it focuses on the people around the table.

  • It looks beyond the CV: It uncovers where people actually feel equipped to speak up, ask probing questions, and offer constructive support.
  • It highlights hidden strengths: You might discover a governor with no formal finance background who brings fantastic community insights, or someone who feels deeply confident asking the right questions about pupil wellbeing.
  • No more wasted time: Instead of Chairs or Clerks spending hours compiling results that rarely get looked at again, we do the analysis for you. You get a clear, visual report designed to actually be read, discussed, and used in your meetings; complete with tailored questions to help your board reflect on next steps.

What Boards Say

Trusts and boards that have moved away from traditional audits are already seeing the difference.  Schools we have worked with have reflected on their experience with the Skills & Confidence Map.

"The tool provides a holistic, refreshing insight into what our trustees bring to their roles, revealing a clearer view of skills and gaps that directly strengthen our recruitment and board development. Crucially, it considers both professional skillsets and broader community networks, genuinely celebrating governance as a vital volunteer role... Su complements the tool with personalised, highly focused analysis and actionable recommendations, delivering far more value than a traditional tick-box skills audit."

Staffordshire based Multi-Academy Trust

“The Skills & Confidence Map made reflecting on our skillset more meaningful and far less dry than a paper-based skills audit.”

Cheshire based Primary School

Get Ready for the Year Ahead

When you understand where your board’s collective confidence lies, planning training, assigning link roles, and targeting future recruitment becomes far simpler and far more meaningful; giving everyone the confidence they need for the year ahead.

As you get ready for the term ahead, consider swapping the dry audit spreadsheet for a clearer, more person-centred picture of your team's real strengths.

If you or your board would like more information on our Skills and Confidence Map - get in touch.

Posted in Shaping Governance.