The Importance of Local Governance in Education

Locally Led, Strategically Strong: Unlocking the Power of Local Governance for Trust-Wide Impact

Locally Led, Strategically Strong is a campaign developed by Shaping Governance. It is grounded in our practice-led insight, national experience, and the voices of governors we’ve supported across the country. It draws on our research, lived experience, and commitment to keeping governance strategically connected, locally informed, and centred on children. 

Article 1: The Importance of Local Governance in Education

Local governance is a cornerstone of the education system. At its heart are the dedicated, skilled, and passionate volunteers, people who care deeply about their schools, their communities, and the futures of children and young people. Local governance connects trust strategy with school reality, bridging the gap between high-level decision-making and the day-to-day needs of individual schools. When empowered, it brings accountability, insight, and inclusion to the forefront, ensuring that local context and community needs inform decisions. This article explores why purposeful, well-aligned local governance is essential to driving trust-wide improvement; and what’s at stake when it’s missing.

At the heart of local governance is accountability. Governing bodies scrutinise decisions, monitor progress, and ensure that strategies are rooted in the needs of their communities. Without this oversight, schools risk defaulting to standardised trust approaches that ignore the unique challenges and strengths of their pupils and localities. Through our work at Shaping Governance, we have consistently found that where local governance is effective, schools and their multi-academy trusts (MATs) are more focused, responsive, and outcomes-driven.

Local governance is also the window on its school, a trusted, informed view into how the school is functioning, how the community perceives it, and how it is meeting the needs of its pupils. It enables trusts and leaders to see what's happening on the ground, not from a distance, but through a lens of genuine understanding and engagement. When functioning well, this window offers immediate, relevant insights rooted in lived experience.

Equally vital is the inclusive structure that local governance enables. Governing bodies are one of the few spaces in the education system where parents, staff, and community members come together as equals. This diversity of voice ensures that decisions are shaped by lived experience, cultural insight, and a genuine understanding of what matters most to children and families. This inclusive, collaborative approach promotes shared responsibility and helps embed education more deeply within the fabric of the community.

Perhaps most critically, local governance keeps education child-centred. Every community has its own story, demographic, and challenges; a one-size-fits-all approach doesn't work. Local governance enables a tailored response that reflects needs and aspirations. Through governance, schools can remain agile, adapting to context in ways that lead to better engagement, stronger relationships, and improved outcomes.

The benefits of strong local governance: A closer look

Local governance doesn't just fill a compliance role; it directly impacts the effectiveness and success of schools within a MAT. Here are some of the key benefits that local governance can bring, shaping a stronger, more connected educational system:

  1. Enhanced strategic focus
    When local governance is empowered, it becomes a dynamic source of insight that helps align trust-wide strategies with the unique needs of individual schools. A well-informed governing body provides timely, on-the-ground feedback, allowing leadership to fine-tune strategy and adapt approaches based on local realities. This ensures that trust-level decisions reflect the lived experience of pupils, staff, and communities.
  2. Strengthened community connections
    Local governance fosters a deeper connection between schools and their communities. It creates an inclusive space where the voices of parents, staff, governors and local leaders come together to ensure that decisions are rooted in the community’s specific needs and values. Strong local governance ensures that schools are not isolated from their environment but instead become an integral part of a collaborative network that supports student success.
  3. Increased accountability and transparency
    Effective local governance enhances accountability by providing a crucial layer of oversight. This means that governance is not just reactive; it proactively challenges, scrutinises, and ensures that strategic goals are being met. When local governance is well-aligned with the trust's overall vision, it holds all levels of leadership accountable to the communities they serve, creating a transparent decision-making process that fosters trust across the system.
  4. Agility in decision-making
    In an educational landscape that is constantly evolving, local governance offers the flexibility to respond quickly to emerging issues. Whether it's a shift in student demographics, changes in local policy, or evolving educational needs, local governance ensures that MATs remain adaptable and can make informed decisions that reflect real-time challenges. This responsiveness allows trusts to stay relevant and continue driving positive outcomes for their schools.
  5. Better engagement and outcomes for students
    At its core, local governance is about ensuring that schools are child-centred. When governance structures are rooted in the needs of their communities, the decisions they make have a direct impact on student engagement and outcomes. With a deep understanding of the local context, local governance can advocate for and implement strategies that create more engaging, inclusive, and supportive learning environments. This leads to improved student outcomes, fostering a stronger, more positive school culture.

Addressing Challenges in Local Governance

However, our Shaping Governance research shows that the potential of local governance in MATs is too often unrealised. In our recent findings, 66% of local governance structures across MATs reported a lack of clarity about the trust's strategic vision and direction. This lack of clarity isn't just a communications issue; it's a leadership challenge that risks undermining the effectiveness of governance altogether. Governance can quickly become disconnected and disempowered without a shared sense of purpose and direction.

Even more concerning, 76% of local governance structures told us they do not feel confident about what pupils and parents think, signalling a critical breakdown in feedback loops and undermining a key strength of local governance: its ability to bring the community insight into the decision-making table. When local boards feel unsure or excluded, trusts lose access to the rich, contextual insight they need to make effective decisions for children.

This gap is not inevitable; it’s an opportunity. As Emma Hawker, Impact and Projects Manager at Governors for Schools, emphasised in her appearance on The National College podcast, local governance becomes transformative when it is “clear, empowered, and connected.” In this form, governance shifts from a compliance role to a driver of cultural alignment and trust-wide improvement. Strong local governance, she notes, ensures that trust leaders are “informed and influenced by those who know their schools best.”

When Shaping Governance was founded in 2017, Su, its founder, saw firsthand that local governance had untapped potential to drive meaningful change. She recognised its structural importance and local governors’ depth of insight, care, and commitment. Shaping Governance was built to strengthen that potential and give local governance the clarity, confidence, and connectivity it needs to move beyond observation and into impact. By focusing on what makes governance effective in practice, the work has helped ensure that local voices are heard and actively shape the direction of their schools and trusts.

The need for this clarity and connection is only growing. According to the Confederation of School Trusts’ 2024 National School Trust Survey, 66% of MATs plan to grow. With expansion comes complexity, and without strong local governance, the risk is that local identity, responsiveness, and community voice will be diluted. In contrast, when governance is strong and clearly linked to strategic decision-making, it provides the framework for equitable, child-focused, and community-driven growth.

Shaping Governance has seen firsthand how embedding strong, connected local governance structures leads to better educational outcomes, stronger engagement, and deeper community trust. It’s not enough to have governance in place; it must be equipped, aligned, and empowered to drive change.

In conclusion, local governance is not a nice-to-have; it’s a strategic necessity for any trust serious about improvement, accountability, and meaningful inclusion. As MATs grow, the governance layer must grow with them, becoming not weaker and more distant, but stronger, clearer, and closer to the people they serve. Local governance is the window on its school; and when that window is open, transparent, and connected, it becomes a powerful driver of trust-wide impact and educational transformation.

Next time we examine the view of a Chair of a Local Governing Body...


Posted in Shaping Governance.