360° External Review of Governance (ERG) for Multi-Academy Trusts

A 360° ERG is an independent, structured review providing objective assurance, sharp insight and practical, prioritised recommendations across the whole trust governance system.

Designed specifically for Multi-Academy Trusts, it evaluates how governance operates across layers: from Members and Trustees to Local Governance and Executive Leadership, ensuring clarity of roles, strong accountability and strategic alignment. Our approach is rigorous yet proportionate: challenging where necessary, constructive throughout, and always focused on strengthening strategic impact.

Our MAT ERG Tiered Approach

We offer three scalable tiers to match the size and complexity of your Trust:

Tier 1 – Trust Board Strategic Review: Focused evaluation of the Trust Board and its links with local governance.

Tier 2 – Trust-Wide Insight Map: Board review plus deployment of our Skills & Confidence Map across local boards, creating a Trust-wide governance dashboard.

Tier 3 – Comprehensive Whole-Trust Review: A full ecosystem review across Members, Trustees and Local Boards, with targeted, prioritised recommendations for each governance layer.

Whether preparing for inspection or building capacity for growth, our tiered approach ensures proportionate, tailored assurance.

Shaping Governance three-tier MAT review framework showing Trust Board, Insight Map, and Whole-Trust development layers

What Makes Our ERGs Different

Our approach combines professional rigour with genuine care. Unlike standard audits, we are known for being:

  • Appreciative: We build on what is already working well, rather than starting from a deficit position;
  • Evidence-Informed: Our framework is fully aligned with national guidance, statutory standards, and regulatory expectations;
  • Structured and Proven: We use a clear, well-tested framework that brings consistency and assurance to every review;
  • Practical: We offer realistic recommendations that boards can act on immediately, paired with the specific tools to deliver them;
  • Respectful and Collaborative: We create a safe, honest space for challenge, reflection, and learning.
We don’t hand over a report and step away. We stay alongside boards, supporting them to turn insight into meaningful improvement that lasts.

The Shaping Governance Difference

  • Skills & Confidence Map: one year’s access to our digital development roadmap

  • Implementation Toolkit & Recognition Plaque: turning insight into action and celebrating commitment to excellence

This is not a tick-box review; it is a focused opportunity to strengthen strategic oversight and alignment so governance delivers better outcomes for children and communities.

A Whole-Trust, 360° External Review of Governance for MATs

Our MAT 360° ERG examines governance across the trust, not just the board.

It explores how effectively each governance layer connects, communicates and contributes to strong strategic oversight. We review:

  • Trust Board and Committees: strategic clarity, culture, challenge, risk, finance, safeguarding and educational oversight,

  • Members: constitutional role and accountability,

  • Local Governance / School Stakeholder Committees: delegated authority, local intelligence and assurance flows,

  • Executive Leadership: reporting quality, transparency and strategic alignment,

  • Key Stakeholders: including Chairs and governance professionals where appropriate.

This whole-system lens ensures governance operates as a connected ecosystem, with clear accountability and aligned purpose.

Our Evidence-Based 360° Process

We combine a focused review of governance documents with confidential stakeholder conversations and live board observation to assess culture, challenge and strategic oversight. Findings are shaped into a prioritised action plan through an Insight & Improvement workshop, followed by a six-month review to ensure lasting impact.

External Review of Governance - Frequently Asked Questions

How often should we have an External Review (ERG)?

The DfE recommends that both Maintained Schools and Academy Trusts commission an external review every three years. It is also best practice during leadership transitions, structural changes, or when preparing for growth.

What is a MAT Capacity Review?

For Multi-Academy Trusts considering expansion, we focus on form, function, and capacity. This ensures your central governance and local tiers are robust and scalable enough to support additional schools effectively.

Do Shaping Governance reviews align with 2026 standards?

Yes. Our framework is mapped against the latest DfE standards for all sectors, including the specific expectations for both Academy Trusts and Maintained Schools.

How do we choose the right provider for an ERG?

The DfE suggests boards look for a balance of independence and high-level expertise. To find the right fit for your school or trust, we recommend checking three things:

  • Current Practicing Expertise: Ensure your reviewer has "on-the-ground" experience. Shaping Governance reviewers are active practitioners, ensuring advice is realistic, not theoretical. All reviews are quality-assured by our CEO, Su Turner, a recognised national expert.

  • Beyond the Report: Many providers deliver a static document and say goodbye. Look for a process that includes implementation support; like our 6-month progress check and digital Skills Map, to ensure the review leads to lasting impact.

  • Sector Alignment: The reviewer must be fluent in the latest standards. Our framework is fully mapped to the Academy Trust Governance Guide and the Maintained Schools Governance Guide.

How do we prepare for an External review (ERG)?

Preparation is minimal. Our 360° process is designed to be non-disruptive, as we take a retrospective look at how governance has functioned over the last 12 months.

  • The "Heavy Lifting" is Ours: We conduct a deep-dive audit of your existing minutes, agendas, and schemes of delegation to understand your board’s journey.

  • Governance in Action: We observe a live meeting to see how these processes translate into real-world culture and challenge.

  • Your Input: We use 1:2:1 conversations to capture the "lived experience" of governors and trustees.

The result is a comprehensive, authentic view of your effectiveness without the need for you to create new "evidence" or reports for the review.

How long does the review process take?

A typical 360° review is conducted over 6 to 10 weeks. This allows for a thorough document audit, 1:2:1 interviews, and a live board or committee meeting observation without disrupting your regular cycle.

What makes the Shaping Governance "360°" approach different?

Most providers deliver a report and exit. We include a 6-month progress check and 12 months of access to our Skills and Confidence Map to ensure recommendations translate into lasting culture change and momentum.

What are Shaping Governance's unique tiered options for governance reviews in Multi-Academy Trusts (MATs)?

We recognise that MAT governance is complex and multi-layered. In our unique approach, we offer three distinct tiers of review to ensure our support matches your Trust’s current size, structure, and strategic needs:

  • Tier 1: Trust Board Strategic Review: A focused evaluation of the Trust Board’s effectiveness, specifically auditing the "form and function" of your connections and communication with Local Governing Bodies (LGBs).

  • Tier 2: The Trust-Wide Insight Map:  A digital-led review using our Skills and Confidence Map across all local boards, plus a Trust Board review element. This provides the Trust Board with a high-level dashboard of capability, role clarity, and governance health across the entire Trust.

  • Tier 3: Comprehensive Whole-Trust Review: Our most robust offer, deep-diving into all layers of governance (Members, Trustees, and Local Boards). This evaluates the entire "governance ecosystem" to ensure accountability and vision are delivered at every level, and includes targeted development support for your local governance tiers.

"Through a rigorous and robust process, with the engagement of governance and senior leaders, Su was able to provide, at school and MAC level, a clear evaluation of how we can enhance performance and improve further.  Su also recognised the distinctive difference of our MAC with a Catholic dimension"

Romero Catholic Academy
'What an amazing addition Su Turner has been to our reflect and review process for school governance She brings a wealth of experience and is a patient facilitator who brings out the very best in our governing body... We start each academic year with our Shaping Governance review.'

Nikki Lawton, Head at Pebble Brook School
"Su’s approach is participative and guides Elected Members through what good corporate parenting looks like so that they can benchmark their approach. Elected Members are key to good corporate parenting and they leave the training programme understanding their role as a Corporate Parent and practical ways in which they can carry out the role effectively."

Dr Lee-Anne Farach, Medway Council
"We highly recommend Shaping Governance to other MACs or MATs that are looking to review their governance. It’s a very supportive and productive process. Su is incredibly professional. The process has exceeded our expectations.”

Local Government Association
"Su has an outstanding reputation in governance, health, and education, playing a key strategic role in enabling effective partnerships and positive outcomes for charities and public sector bodies throughout the UK. She is dynamic in her approach, working at the cutting edge of thinking at a regional and national level. Organisations in the public, private and charitable sectors would benefit from her insights and ability to bring people together to improve outcomes for their customers/clients."

Laura Murphy, Mtc2 Ltd